Sunday, July 22, 2012

Laughing at the Medusa

Cixous' "Laugh of the Medusa" attempts to inspire women to write from a feminist standpoint and create text from the psyche of the woman.

As we discussed in class, Cixous seems to write in a PMS riddled rage that comes across as scatterbrained and somewhat rude. Cixous structures her writing in a very confusing manner - whereas normal writing structure would be: Introduction Points A,B,C (etc.) with subpoints and a conclusion; Cixous seems to throw this method aside. Her introduction starts off strong enough: it's a rally cry for women to write as woman instead of taking a masculine approach to text. From there her approach seems to take a dive. In a sense, I can see Cixous transforming into a Medusa herself - her hair turns into snakes and her writing seems to turn to stone. She changes from rallying women together to completely going against anything that has to do with masculinity and writing.

Cixous also goes off on random tangents with disrupts her writing structure. These tangents do not help her cause of trying to "write like a woman." Instead, they make her sound like she does not in fact know what she is talking about. Her cause is lost amongst the ramblings and side thoughts she inserts into her writing. Writing like this does not make me want to read what she has to say - in fact it does the exact opposite, it shuts me down. I feel intimidated by her writing style because of her approach to "telling me what to do" instead of leading me to write that way. I don't want to be told what to do, I want to be influenced, inspired, to write a certain way. Maybe it's my stubbornness, or maybe Cixous is just a bad writer.

The way I see it is women already write for "woman," because we are women and there is a definite difference between writing styles of men and women. Women will respond better to texts written by women if they are in a coherently structured - it is wrong of Cixous to imply that women are being subdued by men's writing whereas I think it is the exact opposite. It is a choice as to what women read and write and just because women write a certain way does not mean their writing is ineffective and that they should write more masculine in order to get their points across. I firmly believe that because we are wired to read a certain way - which isn't wrong in any way, just how we were taught - that the most effective way might actually be that structure of writing. If it is structured in a way that both women and men can understand it, instead of writing in tangents about what pisses you off about women writing, the point may not be lost as it was in "Laugh of the Medusa."

1 comment:

  1. Felicia,

    This is a good critique. I think writers with political messages are often dealing with the conundrum of wanting to communicate effectively, but also wanting to change the way in which we communicate. Perhaps it would have been more effective for you if she had written in both the dominant discourse and her own style?

    ReplyDelete